Beating a New York City Red light Ticket
It is very important to fight any traffic ticket you receive from a police officer in New York City. This article considers one of the most issued summonses and a very expensive one (over $200 for a first offense) which allocates 3 persistent violator points on your license; namely, a NYC red light violation.
Before we get to discuss the elements of a NYC traffic violation, or a VTL section 1111d1, let’s examine how NYC traffic courts differ from those in almost every other part of NYS. Let’s take Westchester County as representative of the rest of NYS as opposed to Manhattan County, which will stand in for the five boroughs.
In Manhattan, you can’t plea bargain an 1111D1. So, even if your record is perfect, the court will require a hearing. If you lose at the hearing, bang!!! — 3 points and an over $200 fine. In Westchester, if you get a red light ticket, you will be allowed to plea bargain. In most cases, you will receive a non-point violation for your efforts.
In addition, many more red light tickets are issued in NYC then elsewhere in NYS. This happens because NYC is so populous. Also, the evidence and proedure rules in NYC are far more favorable to police then those in the rest of NYS. The burden of proof in NYC is lower for the police then in the rest of the state too.
So, what can a lawyer do for you in New York City traffic court regarding a red light ticket. The punishment for committing an offense of passing a red light is more severe is NYC then it is in other parts of the state due to the large population density in NYC as compared to other parts of the state, like say, Walton, New York. The fine amount is higher for NYC traffic violation and there are mandatory penalties in NYC. That said, a competent and experienced lawyer is your best defense in beating a NYC red light ticket.
A lawyer must be familiar with the elements of a NYC red light violations. Some of the elements are 1. The light was working in all phases prior to and after the stop; 2. The motorist disobeyed a circular disc light or directional arrow light signal; 3. No other officer was directing traffic; 4. No emergency vehicles were present; 5. An accurate description of the roadway including a stop line or pedestrian cross walk or both, and 6. A description of where the motorist was in terms of the intersection prior to the stop, etc.
Further, a lawyer experienced in NYC traffic court knows the quirks and ticks of a particular judge and knows which elements of the people’s case are the most important to that judge. As you can see, it is quite beneficial to use a qualified traffic attorney to fight your DMV summons for you at NYC traffic court.
Michael Spevack, Esq. is a NYC traffic ticket lawyer with more then 15 years experience in beating traffic tickets in NYC. He is a graduate of NYU School of Law, and would be glad to help you beat your summons. Visit Michael Spevack, Esq.’s web sitte now.
Tags: attorney nyc, law, lawyer
